When it comes to maintaining a clean home that is free of dust, there are a lot of mixed opinions on carpets. Some homeowners argue that it has no impact on dust levels while others argue that it makes a room dustier. I figured that it would make sense for me to settle the debate by exploring different perspectives. This article will provide a comprehensive answer to the following question – does carpet make a room dustier?
No, carpets do not make a room dustier. The implication of saying that something has the ability to make a space more dustier is that it produces and spreads more dust. That couldn’t be further from the truth. The issue with carpet is that it traps dust due to its structural ability to hold particles that settle onto and into its surface.
Things like dirt, debris, dust, pollen, and dander can definitely get stuck in and on carpets much more than any other type of flooring.
Due to the porous nature of carpet, it has the ability to soak up moisture. This is a problem for homeowners who dread the onset of mold, mildew, and other types of pathogens. It is a fact that these pathogens thrive in an environment that is cold, dark, and wet. Also, pests like dust mites feed off material that is used to make most carpets.
So, the real issue with carpet is that it can be a trapping zone for dirt and dust and a breeding zone for mold and other pathogens.
What Are The Issues With Carpets?
The only reason why people feel like carpets make a room dusty is that it’s harder to remove dust from a carpet than it is from a floor made from wood, ceramic tiles, vinyl, or stone.
These types of flooring do not have a surface that can trap dust so it’s easier to clean and remove dust from these floors than it is with carpets.
Again, I have to state that it is true that carpets trap dust far more than any other type of flooring.
Ironically, the same mechanism that traps dust also offers a positive side effect for homeowners with sinus issues. It can reduce the amount of dust that is airborne by trapping them. So, in that way, carpets offer a solution to airborne dust issues.
Another issue to consider is cleaning.
With regular flooring, you could remove a ton of dust every day by just sweeping and dusting for a few minutes. There are not many places for dust to get trapped, so you can easily clean floors that are dusty.
That isn’t the case with carpets.
Given that carpets trap dust, sweeping isn’t an effective strategy for removing dust and debris. It may remove loose surface-level dust and dirt but not much more than that.
To keep carpets dust free, you have to vacuum them regularly. On average, you would have to vacuum carpets once per week and more if you have a home with high foot traffic or if you live in an area with a tropical climate.
It is highly recommended that you invest in a high-quality vacuum cleaner with a HEPA filter to effectively capture and remove dust that is deeply trapped within the carpet fibers.
For other types of pathogens, you can’t just mop the carpet like you would with non-material-based flooring.
With carpets, you have to deep clean them periodically and this will require you to use a steam cleaner, a shampoo, and a vacuum. In some cases, you may even need to hire a professional carpet cleaning business to disinfect and deep clean the carpets in your home.
Is Dust More Visible On Carpets Or Hardwood Floors?
Here’s where things get a little confusing.
Carpets may trap more dust than hard flooring but dust is far more visible on hard flooring than it is on carpets. This can create the illusion of a less dustier floor because of the concealing nature of carpet but in reality, it may be dustier and dirtier than hardwood floors.
This is why it’s so important to implement a cleaning regimen to maintain dust-free and clean carpets.
If you have any concerns about air quality, they would be warranted. People with respiratory or sinus issues are more prone to flare-ups and issues with carpets than they are to hardwood floors.
The only way to mitigate this issue is to have a system in place that encourages regular vacuuming and steam cleaning. Also, you would need to invest some money into a good quality air filter that can clean the air from dust and allergens before they get trapped on the carpet.
A great investment would be a robot vacuum cleaner!
I absolutely adore them because they are so non-obtrusive yet effective at maintaining clean carpets with minimal effort from you.
You could drastically reduce the amount of effort and time you need to put into vacuuming and cleaning carpets by having one of these robot vacuum cleaners suck up dust throughout the day.
Final Thoughts
I hope that by this point, you have a good idea of whether or not carpet makes a room dustier. Honestly, in my experience and opinion, I would argue that it doesn’t make a room dustier but it does contribute to the collection of dust.
This can be remedied or solved by implementing a cleaning system that regularly removes dust from the carpet and minimizes the amount of dust that does enter the room in the first place.
My advice to you would be to invest in an air purifier and a robot vacuum. These two devices can eliminate or minimize the downside of carpets trapping dust in a room.
If you can get those two items or if you can vacuum carpets weekly, I don’t see any reason why you couldn’t enjoy the comfort, warmth, and visual appeal of carpets in a room.
Related Posts
What stains are permanent on carpet?